Why Lincoln Wasn’t The Greatest President: The Research Paper
Introduction
President Lincoln, among many people, is regarded as ‘the greatest president in American history’. This is a very easy mistake to make, given to titles like ‘the Great Emancipator’ or ‘Honest Abe’ and the history books stating that he was some kind of saint. Unfortunately, none of this is true. This comes as a shock to many people due to his legendary status, but it is true. Underneath Lincoln’s likable facade lay a tyrannic, dictator like mentality, prepared to do anything in his own personal interests.
Lincoln’s Shocking Views on Slavery
racism
noun
The first thing that must be mentioned when speaking of Lincoln is his stance on slavery. You might be of the opinion that Lincoln absolutely hated slavery. While I wish this was true, it isn’t. Lincoln himself expressed his support for the practice.
- Lincoln’s direct statements indicated his support for slavery. He defended slave owners’ right to own their property, stating that “when they remind us of their constitutional rights [to own slaves], I acknowledge them, not grudgingly but fully and fairly; and I would give them any legislation for the claiming of their fugitives” (in indicating support for the Fugitive Slave Act of 1850). (Dilorenzo x)
‘But didn’t he support the Emancipation Proclamation?’ you may ask. Lincoln, in a letter to Treasury Secretary Salmon P. Chase, admitted that it was a political gimmick purely to boost his status, saying “The original proclamation has no…legal justification, except as a military measure.” Furthermore, Lincoln sought no equality between whites and blacks. While you might refute that with Lincoln’s statement in the Gettysburg Address that all people are equal, you must remember that Lincoln was a politician. Famous Economist Murray Rothbard said it best, saying that “Lincoln was a master politician, which means that he was a consummate conniver, manipulator, and liar.” That makes this quote from Lincoln far more credible to the modern ear:
- “I have no purpose to introduce political and social equality between the white and black races. There is a physical difference between the two, which, in my judgement, will probably forever forbid their living together upon the footing of perfect equality; and inasmuch as it becomes a necessity that there must be a difference, I, as well as Judge Douglas, am in favor of the race to which I belong having the superior position. I have never said anything to the contrary.”
Lincoln said that in 1858 during a debate with Senator Stephen Douglas in Ottawa, Illinois. Good grief. If anyone said that today, they would immediately be called a racist and probably shot or something else terrible.
Lincoln also, while serving in the Illinois legislature, “never challenged the anti-black legislation of his state, voting against black suffrage and refusing to sign a petition allowing black testimony in court. Lincoln was also a strong supporter of colonizing freed blacks, convinced that they could never be assimilated into American society.” (Woods, 67)
It’s starting to sound like, at this point, that Lincoln was a massive racist. And keep in mind too, that nothing I’ve mentioned includes his presidency. To find that stuff out, I would point to Thomas J. Dilorenzo’s The Real Lincoln, and Brion McClanahan’s 9 Presidents Who Screwed Up America. They are both great reads, and fill in the blanks that most history scholars like to conveniently forget about.
Lincoln’s Flagrant Abuses of Power and the Violation of His Oath of Office
The Constitution was, during the 1860’s, a highly respected document. It had been highly respected since the days of the founding fathers, when early presidents would veto propositions simply because they were not mentioned in that document. The respect of the Constitution vanished when Lincoln became president, however. When Lincoln was sworn in, he began a series of very unconstitutional acts, such as:
- “declaring martial law; blockading the Southern ports; suspending the habeas corpus for the duration of his administration; imprisoning without trial thousands of Northern citizens; arresting and imprisoning newspaper publishers who were critical of him; censoring all telegraph communication; nationalizing the railroads; creating several new states without the consent of the citizens of those states; ordering Federal troops to interfere with elections in the North by intimidating Democratic voters; deporting a member of Congress, Clement L. Vallandigham of Ohio, for criticizing the administration’s income tax proposal at a Democratic Party rally; confiscating private property; confiscating firearms in violation of the Second Amendment; and effectively gutting the Ninth and Tenth amendments to the Constitution, among other things.” (Dilorenzo, 131-32)
What is habeas corpus? It allowed so called ‘enemies of the state’ and political prisoners to be released from captivity following established legal procedures. This law also protected American citizens from arbitrary arrest for whatever reason. However, on April 27, 1861, Lincoln decided that this concept was no longer necessary, ordering the military to enforce it. This meant that Lincoln now had the ability to arbitrarily arrest anyone for whatever he pleased, usually people who mildly opposed him on the political field or people who criticized him in newspapers or telegrams. This suspension remained in effect for his entire presidency.
The Final Verdict
Overall, I will leave the decision up to you. Based on the evidence, I personally think Lincoln was an awful president, but you may have different thoughts. The important thing to keep in mind, despite whatever we think, is to not blindly trust what everyone else says. Just because someone has a piece of paper with their name on it doesn’t mean that they know the whole story. Always corroborate with various sources.
You do want to have free thought, don’t you?
Biblography
Dilorenzo, Thomas J. The Real Lincoln. Roseville, California: Prima Publishing, 2002, Hardcover
McClanahan, Brion. 9 Presidents Who Screwed Up America, and 4 Who Tried to Save Her. Washington, DC: Regnery History, 2016, Hardcover
Woods, Thomas E, Jr, Ph.D. The Politically Incorrect Guide to American History. Washington, DC: Regnery History, 2004, Paperback